I kind of hate to say it, but I agree completely on this one.

EnigmaticMan has been on a couple of times since I joined the site. We had a brief conversation in Latin (neither of us are very good at composition), and I respected his smarts greatly. I would greatly enjoy engaging in a battle of minds with him. Perhaps that would, if your observation is correct, determine forthright which of your two selections truly is the intellectual superior?

I'll support that one.

TheThinker was not very philosophical. He may have made philosophically-themed debates, but they were done in what I consider to be an immature manner.